Four years after their first conversation on Citizen Media News over Zoom, host Roger Farina and Peter Ticktin finally met face to face in Las Vegas.
There was something fitting about the setting. Over the next hour, two men connected by military school would move through old court cases, Donald Trump, election machines, January 6 and memories of an America that, in Ticktin’s telling, was built differently.
Farina, who once worked at West Point, began with the New York Military Academy man sitting across from him.
Who is Peter Ticktin?
“I’m an attorney,” Ticktin said.
It was a simple answer with a complicated history behind it.
In March 2022, Ticktin’s firm helped put Donald Trump’s name on a civil complaint against Hillary Clinton, the DNC and the Russia collusion roster. That same week, Citizen Media News aired Ticktin describing Trump as an honors student, an honest man and a good guy, and recalling stories from their academy years.
Four years later, Farina wanted to know what still held up—and what Ticktin might do differently.
Ticktin was careful about his role. He was not lead counsel, he said. He was directed, others were involved, and there were things he could not discuss. But he was clear about what he wanted: a judge who would stand by the law and the Constitution, not an activist and not a homer.
“We don’t need anybody who takes our side,” he said.
Then, he said, they got Middlebrooks, and the case went downhill.
Farina pressed him on what he would change. Ticktin smiled. They were, after all, sitting in Las Vegas—the old mob town—talking about those cases.
But the more revealing stories came from long before Trump entered politics.
After the indictments, raids, gag orders and two attempts on Trump’s life, Farina asked whether Ticktin still believed the man he once called a “good guy” was the same man.
Ticktin did.
He called Trump an honest man because, he said, that is what he is.
To explain why, Ticktin went back to New York Military Academy, where character was measured less by what a man said than by how he lived when someone was inspecting the corners.
Trump was on the first floor. Ticktin was upstairs on the second. Their first year, they were in different companies. Inspections were war. Dust on a locker could sink you. Wool blankets shed fuzz onto floors already polished with Pledge.
You do not really know a man, Ticktin said, until you share a section of the barracks.
Farina asked which memory people still wanted to hear most: Trump helping a smaller student or the infamous ketchup-cap story.
The ketchup won.
Had Ticktin known what was coming, he said, he would have sat down and eaten. Instead, the punishment was ten shots with a broomstick—worse than a fraternity paddle. If the broom broke, they got another stick.
That would not fly today, both men agreed.
Decades later, discipline remained at the heart of Ticktin’s argument—this time about elections.
He wants the president to issue a more specific emergency order and put the Tina Peters plan in play: Let the machines count, then send the ballots straight to a hand audit.
“That is all I am asking,” he said.
Ticktin believes the failure is in the machines. Ballots elsewhere matter, he said, but the machines are the problem. His answer is an audit and, ultimately, getting rid of the machines.
Hand-counting 200 million votes sounds enormous until the job is divided, he argued. It is not one man counting 200 million ballots. Spread the work out, and it can be done. Do that, he said, and people can trust the election.
Tina Peters remains unfinished business for Ticktin. So do January 6 clients. More than 100 wrongful-conviction and money fights, he said, are still alive.
Farina remembers January 6 from another vantage point.
He was on the other side of the Capitol singing “God Bless America” and the national anthem, unaware of what was happening on the far side. He had walked from a cold, muddy Washington Monument while Trump was still speaking when he saw men already wearing helmets, flak vests, goggles and tactical masks.
Those men had shown up dressed for combat, Farina said, before any line in Trump’s speech could have sent them.
The question of accountability brought the interview back to Trump.
What form of harassment had hurt him most? Who had been held accountable?
“Not yet,” Ticktin said.
He named John Brennan. Things were not nearly what they used to be, he said, but he was not sure anyone was close.
By then, the conversation had stretched well beyond one man or one presidency. Kennedy and the Cuban missile years surfaced, and Ticktin remembered a harder country.
Hard times make hard men. Hard men make easy times. Easy times make soft men. Soft men make hard times.
Kennedy’s assassination, he said, put people crying in the streets and shook America to its roots. September 11 killed many, but losing a president felt more personal.
And if a fool ever took out Trump, Ticktin said, that man would discover what Booth learned after Lincoln.
No place to run.
Ticktin’s book is still on Amazon. His shop is LegalBrains.com.
“Lawyers with brains,” he said.
And with that, the attorney, the old classmate and the stories that had traveled four years through a screen finally had their day in Las Vegas.
The book is still on Amazon. The shop is LegalBrains.com. Lawyers with brains, he said. Four years after the Zoom talks, the classmate from Company A was finally in the room.